As Hollywood’s WGA and SAG strikes hit Labor Day, how studio chiefs misread the writers room

As Hollywood’s WGA and SAG strikes hit Labor Day, how studio chiefs misread the writers room

Mario Tama/Getty Pictures

SAG-AFTRA members picket with hanging Writers Guild of America employees outdoors Paramount Studios in August.


If Hollywood studio chiefs have a popularity as expert dealmakers, a Labor Day that finds their key staff nonetheless out on strike after 4 months underscores simply how badly they misread the writers room.

The historical past of Hollywood labor actions has seen main corporations depend on their deeper pockets to soak up the ache and wait out their staff. Arguably, that benefit seems much more pronounced at the moment, with the studios joined at the bargaining desk by large firms like Amazon and Apple, which function their very own streaming companies as they expanded into the programming recreation.

The studios, whose Alliance of Movement Image and Tv Producers is called the AMPTP (of which CNN mother or father Warner Bros. Discovery is a member), clearly appear to have anticipated that situation unfolding in these negotiations. Whether or not true or not, the notion that the objective was to crush guild resistance was stoked by a now-notorious quote attributed to an nameless government on the commerce web site Deadline, “The endgame is to permit issues to tug on till union members begin dropping their flats and dropping their homes.”

What the studios someway missed, or selected to disregard, was the shared perception by the guilds representing writers and actors that this represents an inflection level for the leisure business, forcing them to take a stand now. So quite than shaking their resolve, such inflammatory sentiments strengthened it, based mostly on the assumption that it’s higher to chew the bullet and stick collectively now, hoping to keep away from one other prolonged work stoppage over the subsequent contract, or the one after that.

Certainly, writers and actors have rallied round the notion their present sacrifices will profit not simply them however the generations that comply with them. As a mannequin for that they level to 1960 – the final time the Writers Guild and Display screen Actors Guild struck at the identical time, when Ronald Reagan was president of the latter – that yielded signature concessions relating to residuals, or performers sharing in studio income over time.

Whereas studios won’t have a lot credibility on the subject of pleading poverty, they’ve some extent fretting about the future. The shift towards streaming has upended conventional consumption of each motion pictures and tv, casting darkish clouds over their enterprise.

From Apple

Disney CEO Bob Iger angered writers by saying they have been “not practical” with their contract calls for.

Disney CEO

Robert Iger – often one among the most polished company leaders – gave the guilds billboard fodder by looking for to drive dwelling that warning, telling an interviewer what they’re looking for is “not practical,” citing the fragility of the present local weather.

It’s exhausting to disclaim that Hollywood – whose fortunes have usually been constructed and shaken by new expertise – has reached one other crossroads. Though writers and actors can legitimately say that the present streaming-driven malaise isn’t their fault, it’s their downside too, particularly if the corporations reduce on manufacturing, which is a reliable concern.

Nonetheless, executives like Iger have change into poor messengers for fiscal accountability. Guild leaders shrewdly turned the dialog again to studio bosses’ stratospheric earnings ranges, citing, for instance, the $50 million earned by Netflix CEO Ted Sarandos in 2022, prompting a non-binding shareholder vote rejecting the firm’s executive-compensation packages in June.

Whereas minutia about residual funds and how many writers a streaming sequence employs don’t lend themselves to debate in the court docket of public opinion, the studios do seem to have misplaced that battle, as conventional efforts to undermine assist for “grasping” actors and writers – whose best-paid members earn hundreds of thousands as nicely – have largely failed.

When it comes to public notion, Los Angeles Occasions columnist Mary McNamara argued persuasively that the studios have already misplaced the PR battle, signaling that it’s time to swallow their collective pleasure and make a deal.

After all, assembly most of the guilds’ calls for will value the studios further hundreds of thousands annually, possible heightening monetary pressures which have already resulted in layoffs and spending cuts. In that sense, settling the strikes received’t essentially put an finish to Hollywood’s rising (or maybe extra precisely, shrinking) pains.

But if these large corporations nonetheless suppose making motion pictures and TV reveals, no matter the challenges, is a enterprise price being in, they’re going to want any person to write down and act in them. And whereas guild members would like to get again to work, the one factor they’re not going to do after months on the picket traces, no matter the studio’s strategic recreation plan when the strike started, is roll over and play lifeless.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button